What is the best pizza in New York City? The TOP 20 pizza places you NEED to try!

September 27, 2021

Are you searching for the best pizza in New York City? If so, keep reading.

You come to NYC for 2 things… The city, and the pizza. And finding the best pizza in New York City is going to be crucial to making your trip a success. Because the truth is, you can’t visit NYC without trying the pizza here. It’s a part of the lifestyle, the culture, it might as well be the city’s mascot.

the best pizza in New York City

If you’re searching for the best pizza in New York City, then hopefully this list can point you in the right direction. We’ve eaten our way around the city, so you don’t have to.

This list is made up of all of our top choices for the best pizza in New York City, and we promise you, none of them will disappoint. These are the best pizza in New York City, hands down.

So, let’s get started on this epic list of the best pizza in NYC.


Our choices for the best pizza in New York City!


Joe’s pizza

First up on our list of the best pizza in New York City, it’s Joe’s pizza. This is the classic NYC ‘pizza joint’ – and you absolutely NEED to eat here at least once during your trip to NYC. Listen, Joe’s isn’t the fanciest, the most instagrammable, or the trendiest pizza place in NYC – but it’s the iconic grab-and-go style pizza joint that New York City has become famous for.

Order by the slice, because one of the reasons Joe’s is the best pizza in Nee York City, is because of their way of reheating. Large slices are reheated in the oven, which means you get a crispy base and crusty – and an oozy cheesy top. It’s amazing. This has to be some of the best pizza in NYC hands down!


Rubi Rosa

Rubirosa is one of the most well-known pizza places in the city, so it had to make our list of the best pizza in New York City. The pizza here is perfection. It’s fresh, rustic and delicious. Top tip for visiting Rubirosa? Make sure you book ahead. This place is always full.

To be honest, this place is so good, that you can’t really go wrong with anything on the menu – but if you’re feeling fancy, then order their namesake pizza, the Rubirosa Supreme. It is a love letter to pizza, featuring hand-cut spicy pepperoni, diced basil, and mini meatballs. Another iconic choice for the best pizza in NYC!

Read more NYC food recommendations: Top 11 best pastrami sandwiches in NYC

Image credit: https://www.rubirosanyc.com/

Prince Street Pizza

If you’re looking for the best pizza in New York City, but you’re not a huge fan of the thin and crispy variety – then Prince Street Pizza is a fantastic option. This place serves up thick, bready, crusty, loaded pizza – and OMG it’s something else. This is the kind of pizza you dream about.

Their “SoHo Square” slice is the one that went viral, and with it’s with tiny, thick slices of pepperoni loaded on top of their caramelised crust – it’s heavenly and well worth an Instagram post. Another amazing choice for the best pizza in NYC, and somewhere you’ll be talking about for weeks (maybe months) after.

Image credit: https://princestreetpizzanyc.com/

Lucali

Some of the best pizza in New York City, can also be found in Lucali. Lucali is located across the river in Brooklyn, but it’s easy to get to, and worth the trip out of Manhattan.

The pizza in Lucali is a labor of love, and you can taste all the years of perfecting and love that has gone into these pies. It’s owned by pizza guru Mark Iacono, and this place has been visited by celebrities such as Beyonce – so that should be the only seal of approval you require! There are no arguments that this is some of the best pizza in NYC!

Read more NYC food recommendations: 20 of the best cheap lunches in NYC

Image credit: https://www.lucalibrooklyn.com/

Koronet Pizza

Next on our list of the best pizza in New York City, it’s Koronet Pizza. This pizza place in NYC is known for delicious oozy slices, and it’s one of those pizza places you’ll want to visit after a night out drinking. This place is (quite rightly) known for their huge jumbo slices, and (trust us) they won’t disappoint you! With a slice coming in around $5, it’s also a really affordable way to experience some of the best pizza in New York City.


Zazzy’s

Next on our list of the best pizza in New York city, it’s Zazzy’s. This is a great choice for the vegans and vegetarians – as they have a plant-forward menu. There are two NYC locations to pick from, one in the Lower East Side and one in Greenwich Village. Another epic choice for the best pizza in NYC!

Read more NYC food recommendations:15 amazing places to find cheesecake in NYC

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/zazzyspizza/

Coco pizzeria

Coco pizzeria is next on our list of the best pizza in New York City. This place was founded by famous restaurateur Pino Luongo, and pizzaiolo Ciro Verde. You’ll find delicious wood-fired pies here – and (if you fancy branching out a little) you’ll also find their iconic focaccias. This place offers dine-in and takeaway, and it’s seriously worth a visit. This is definitely some of the most unique and the best pizza in NYC!

Image credit: https://www.cocopazzeria.com/

Di Fara Pizza

Another great choice for the best pizza in NYC, is Di Fara Pizza! Di Fara Pizza is one of the oldest, and one of the best pizzas in New York City. You might have spotted this place on the TV show ‘Somebody Feed Phil’ – and if so, you’ll know the amazing story behind this incredible pizza shop in NYC.

Honestly, this isn’t just some of the best pizza in New York City, it’s also the most legendary! It has been around for years – and still offers the tastiest and most delicious around.

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/difarapizzanyc/

John’s of Bleeker

John’s of Bleeker is another classic and iconic choice for the best pizza in New York City. This amazing NYC pizza place was opened by Italian immigrant John Sasso in 1929 (yes this place is that old!). It’s an NYC institution, and it’s an amazing place to grab pizza in the city.

They don’t do slices here (it’s a full pie or nothing) but it’s so delicious that you’ll be thankful for the extra portions! Save some for breakfast the next day! A classic pick for the best pizza in NYC!

Read more NYC food recommendations: 50 amazing places to grab breakfast in NYC

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/johnsofbleeckerstreet/

Emmy Squared

As the name suggests, Emmy Squared offer up delicious pizza in a crispy, crusty square shape, rather than the traditional circular shape. This place is insta-famous, and you’ll probably have seen photos of their square pizzas in your explore feed at some point! We recommend the Roni Supreme (a scrumptious pizza dotted with pepperoni and firey Calabrian chilis).

Image credit: https://www.emmysquaredpizza.com/

Emmett’s Pizza

Next on our list of the best pizza in New York City, it’s Emmett’s Pizza. If you want to make your mouth water, just look at the photo of Emmett’s Pizza’s pizza below! OMG it looks so good. This is what pizza dreams are made of, so of course we had to include it on our list of the best pizza in New York City.

Whilst Emmett’s Pizza does offer thin crust options, you go here for their Chicago-style deep dish pizzas. That’s what they’re known for, and it’s the star of the show. Another reason we love this place? You can design your own pizza and toppings. Choose exactly what you want – and make the most ideal combination for your taste-buds! This is definitely some of the best pizza in NYC.

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/emmettsnyc/

Arturo’s

Arturo’s is next on our list of the best pizza in New York City. This place is a no-frills, but amazing food kinda place. It ozzes old-school vibes, the kind pf pizza place your grandparents might have experienced in NYC back in the day. And that’s kind of the point, and that’s how they like it. The pizza is great, the atmosphere is cosy and homely, and there’s even live jazz too. You’re going to LOVE this place for the best pizza in NYC.

Read more about NYC food: Top 12 best places to eat in Little Italy, NYC


Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop

Next on our list of the best pizza in New York City, it’s Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop. This place is located in Brooklyn, and is home to that gooey, oozy delicious pizza you probably dream about. You can order by the slice, or by the pie, and the prices are really reasonable too! A great place to try some of the best pizza in New York City, especially if you’re based in Brooklyn!

Image credit: https://www.facebook.com/PaulieGeesSliceShop/photos/

Bleecker Street Pizza

Bleecker Street Pizza is one of the most hyped pizza places in NYC, and so (of course) it deserved a spot on our list of the best pizza in New York City. They serve up crispy and delicious thin-crust pizzas, and have some really unique combination of toppings which you should definitely try out!

This place won the title ‘best pizza in New York City’ 3 years in a row – so you know it’s going to be good. Not sure what to order? Their best-selling ‘Nona Marie Pie’ is a classic. It’s an old family recipe, and it’s a local’s favorite, and the perfect place to start!

Image credit: https://www.facebook.com/BleeckerStreetPizza/

Peasant NYC

Next on our list of the best pizza in New York City, it’s Peasant NYC. This Tribeca restaurant isn’t stricly pizza-only, it’s actually one of the city’s best Italian restaurants – so they serve up plenty of other dishes too. It was taken over by chef Marc Forgione, and if you want the pizza, you’ll be ordering their ‘Pizza Picante’ – topped with Pecorino Peperoncino, Soppressata, ‘Nduja.


L&B Spumoni

Next on our list of the best pizza in New York City, it’s L&B Spumoni. The pizza here isn’t your average New York City pizza. It’s thick and rectangular, with a delicious crispy base with so much crunch! It almost feels like a different dish altogether, and some have even liked it to pizza crossed with lasagna!

However you choose to describe it though, it’s still some of the best pizza in New York City. It’s somewhere you simply have to try out during your trip! Another amazing pick for the best pizza in NYC, you have to try it!

Image credit: https://spumonigardens.com/

Corner Slice

You can never have too many pizza slice places. Especially in New York. And Corner Slice is another great place to try some of the best pizza in New York City – and if you’re looking for something cheap, quick and tasty – this is for you. Their square slices are the things pizza dreams are made from! How great does this place look? Another option for the best pizza in NYC you’ll need to add to your list!


Mama’s Too

How could we write a list of the best pizza in New York City, and not include Mama’s Too! This place is located on the Upper West Side, and it’s packing a punch. The pizza here oozes expertise and attention to detail, and even the most basic items on the menu are delicious beyond words.

This is one of the pizza places in NYC, where you can feel the love that has been poured into each and every slice, and it’s absolutely some of the best pizza in NYC.

Read more NYC food recommendations: Where to find the best pancakes in NYC

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/mamas_too/

Scarr’s Pizza

Next up on our list of the best pizza in New York City, it’s Scarr’s Pizza. This place is filled with nostalgia, and will have you feeling like you’ve stepped back into the 1960s. This place is so recognisable and iconic – that they have their own merchandise (something to buy when you’ve had your fill of the pizza).


Song’ E Napule

If you’re looking for Neapolitan pizza in NYC, then this might be the best pizza in New York City for you! Song’ E Napule do the most amazing Neapolitan-inspired pizza, and it definitely stands apart from the crowds. The pizza is fresh and light, and the dough and crust is fluffy and risen (almost like naan bread).

It’s so much different to the traditional NYC crispy thin pizza, and it’s definitely worth trying both if you have time, so make sure you put this amazing pizza place in NYC on your to-do list. A classic choice for the best pizza in NYC, we know you’ll love it.

Read more NYC food recommendations: Where to find the best bagels in NYC

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/songenapulenyc/

We hope this list of the best pizza in New York City has been helpful!

As you can see, there are so many places to find the best pizza in NYC. NYC is brimming with pizza places, and they all offer something unique and different. No two pizzas in this city will ever taster the same! And that’s what we love about searching for the best pizza in New York City! The best pizza in NYC is waiting for you…

Read more about visiting NYC: The ultimate NYC bucket list (80 ideas in the city!)

best pizza in New York City

You Might Also Like