The Best Halloween Costume Stores in NYC: 11 Amazing Stores You’ll LOVE!

August 23, 2021

Are you looking for the best Halloween costume stores in NYC? If so, keep reading!

If you’re looking for the best Halloween costume stores in NYC, then you need to read this list! There’s no other city that celebrates Halloween quite like New York City, with the endless Halloween parties, and amazing Halloween parade – this is one of the best cities to celebrate Halloween!

If you’re visiting the city, then you’ll no doubt be looking for the best Halloween costume stores in NYC! Maybe you want an all-out costume (with all the bells and whistles) or maybe you just need something simple! Whichever vibe you’re going for – this list guarantees to help you find the best Halloween costume stores in NYC.

Also, you don’t have to be that ‘into’ Halloween to enjoy visiting a Halloween costume store in NYC. Even if you don’t have a party planned, sometimes visiting the best Halloween costume stores in NYC can be a super fun date idea or activity to just do for the fun of it!

Anyway… Let’s get into it!


Here are the best Halloween costume stores in NYC!


Abracadabra

Although its name may lend itself more accurately to the magical world, Abracadabra is actually one of the best Halloween costume stores in NYC! Offering everything from accessories to full-blown costumes, this is a spot in the city that will have you walking away with the world’s best Halloween gear. 

Now, we’ll level with you here – this is one of the Halloween costume stores in NYC that ain’t cheap. Sure, everything is extremely well-made and sure to last you at least a couple of Halloweens.

If you’re on the hunt for cheap, use-it-then-lose-it garb, then this isn’t the spot for you. However, if you’re in search of an incredibly ornate or accurate costume, then this is certainly one of the best Halloween costume stores in NYC to check out this year. This is one of the best Halloween costume stores in NYC, so don’t miss it.


Gothic Renaissance

Another fantastic chice for the best Halloween costume stores in NYC, is Gothic Renaissance. Not only does it sound suitably spooky, but Gothic Renaissance is one of the finest Halloween costume stores in NYC for those wanting to impress. The place is decked out with mannequin heads, bits of costume, and oh-so-many studs which may be off-putting for more conservative visitors.

However, once you’ve gotten over the slightly strange gothic aesthetic, you can start digging for weird and wonderful costume items. Although this may not be the best Halloween costume store in NYC for full costumes, it’s an ideal place to stop at if you’re looking for singular, hard-to-find items.

If you need an awesome choker, a tiara, or perhaps a corset, then this is one of the Halloween costume stores in NYC that will sort you out in no time. If you’re feeling particularly supernatural, then be sure to dedicate some time to checking out this Halloween costume store’s selection of tarot cards and other mystical items. Another great choice for the best Halloween costume stores in NYC.


Screaming Mimis

Next on our list of the best Halloween costume stores in NYC, it’s Screaming Mimis. Screaming Mimis isn’t one of the more traditional Halloween costume stores in NYC. Unlike some of the other incredible Halloween costume stores in NYC, this boutique is slightly more upmarket. With a focus on vintage clothing, this is the place to visit if you’re looking to pull off Holly Golightly or a character from The Great Gatsby.

As you might expect, the goodies here are pricier than those you’d find at classic Halloween costume stores in NYC. However, we can vouch for the fact that every item you pick up here is made to last. Seriously, you can recycle the clothing and accessories you purchase here for years to come. This is a great option for the best Halloween costume stores in NYC.

So, if you’re looking for the best Halloween costume stores in NYC that will hit those historical costume requirements hard, then Screaming Mimis is the place to be. 

Image credit: Screaming Mimis

New York Costumes

New York Costumes is next up on our list of the best Halloween costume stores in NYC. Props, wigs, and costumes – oh my! If you’re looking for the aforementioned items, then you’ve come to the right place. New York Costumes isn’t going to break any costuming records, but it does have an immense selection of goodies that you can rifle through for your next Halloween bash.

If you’re feeling lazy this year and don’t fancy investing time into a DIY project, then you’ll be pleased to know that this is one of the best Halloween costume stores in NYC that offers a rental service. Simply pay a few bucks, pick up your costume, and you’re good to go! 


Spirit Halloween

Spirit Halloween is one of the best Halloween costume stores in NYC by a mile. With a reputation that proceeds it, this store is sure to provide everything you’ll need for a rip-roarin’, screamin’ Halloween bash. If you’re wondering what makes Spirit Halloween so special, it’s simple; they stock nearly every costume under the sun.

Seriously, whether you’re looking to dress primly as a girl scout or want to go all-out with a Frankenstein costume, you can find everything you’ll need to pull your look together here. There’s a reason it’s considered one of the best Halloween stores in NYC, after all! 

One word of warning that we could give you is to make sure you allocate plenty of time to exploring this place. It really isn’t small, so you don’t want to feel rushed or risk missing out on the perfect accessory that will pull your look together. This is a perfect choice for the best Halloween costume stores in NYC.


Village Party Store

Another great option for the best Halloween costume stores in NYC, it’s Village Party Store. If you’re on the hunt for party supplies, vibrant costumes, and awesome staff who are always on hand to help, then you should certainly pay a visit to the Village Party Store this October. Although this is a no-frills type of store, it offers an incredible selection of decorations, themed costumes, and accessories.

If we’re being honest, you can probably source everything you’ll need for your party right here. Whether you’re the host or an attendee, this place has got you covered. Now, you should probably be aware that this place is a bit of a lucky dip. It doesn’t have the best organizational setup in the world, but boy does is this a Halloween costume store in NYC with options. You’ll love visiting this option for the best Halloween costume stores in NYC.

With an entire wall dedicated to Halloween makeup alone, you should find everything you’re looking for here. You may just have to dig a little. Despite these shortcomings, we still feel it deserves a spot on our list of the best Halloween costume stores in NYC. 


Frank Bee Costume Center

Frank Bee Costume Center is one of those New York City spots that just exudes Mom and Pop energy, and it’s definitely one of the best Halloween costume stores in NYC. Unlike chain stores, this amazing Halloween costume store in NYC has been around since 1957. Yep – 1957! With distinctly friendly energy and boasting an incredible inventory, you’re highly likely to walk out of this place with exactly what you came in for.

Whatever you want to dress as this year, if you ask a member of staff for the missing piece of your puzzle, they’re likely to walk out of the storeroom with it in hand. Seriously, they’re that good. Another awesome choice for the best Halloween costume stores in NYC.


Halloween Adventure

Halloween Adventure is next on our list of the best Halloween costume stores in NYC. Okay, so Halloween Adventure is definitely one of the best Halloween costume stores in NYC. However, it’s also one of the creepiest. If you’re traveling with kids, then we recommend heading into this spooky spot alone. Once you’ve gotten past the creepy mannequins and scary masks though, you’ll find that this is an amazing Halloween store.

Realistically, you’ve got to give them props for really embracing the meaning of Halloween! With more wigs and costumes than you can take in at first glance, this is a treasure trove of amazing Halloween goodies. Just sift through and see what you can find! Don’t miss out on this choice for the best Halloween costume stores in NYC!


Spark Pretty

Spark Pretty is next uop on our list of the best Halloween costume stores in NYC! Another one of the best Halloween costume stores in NYC for those looking for vintage fare is Spark Pretty. With its psychedelic décor and awesome vintage jacket selection, this is an awesome Halloween costume store in NYC to visit even when you’re not in search of a great costume. 

If you’re feeling uninspired and aren’t sure what you want to dress as this year, then this place is sure to inspire you. Some of the colors may spark something in that brain of yours, so see what you can find and go with your gut! Oh, and don’t be afraid to wear your awesome purchases once Halloween is over. Go on, you know you want to. It’s a great choice for the best Halloween costume stores in NYC.


Ricky’s NYC

If you’ve got a naughty Halloween costume planned, then Ricky’s should be your first port of call. This is one of the Halloween costume stores in NYC that is certainly NSFW, so don’t accidentally waltz in here with the kids! But if you’re looking for the best adults-only Halloween costume stores in NYC, then this might be the right place to check out!

Offering visitors everything from hair dye to sex toys, this is an interesting Halloween costume store in NYC that’s well worth a peek. Hey, even if you’re not heading to a party, you never know what you may pick up at Ricky’s. 


We’re Havin a Party 

And last up on our list of the best Halloween costume stores in NYC, it’s ‘We’re Havin a Party‘. If you want to impress at your next Halloween gathering, then you’ll want to pay a visit to We’re Havin A Party. Now, as you might have guessed from their name, these guys know how to do Halloween with style.

Having been resident in New York for over 30 years, these guys have dressed more Supermen and Cheerleaders than the rest of the city combined. Okay, so that may be an exaggeration, but the folks at We’re Havin A Party are bonafide experts, making this one of the best Halloween costume stores in NYC for just about anything.

Offering visitors everything from princess dresses to outlandish movie costumes, this is one of the Halloween costume stores in NYC that is sure to see you kitted out in no time! So, what are you waiting for? This is definitely a great choice for the best Halloween costume stores in NYC.


Hopefully this list of the best Halloween costume stores in NYC has been helpful!

You Might Also Like