Are you looking for the best cookies in NYC? If so – keep reading for all our favorite picks!
In search of the best cookies in NYC? We’ve searched the city (it’s a hard job, but someone has to do it) sampling all the city’s best cookies, so we could make the ultimate list for you.
This list is going to give you so many amazing recommendations and places to visit! So you’re in NYC and you have a cookie craving… This list is going to tell you exactly where to visit for the best cookies in NYC.
There are so many amazing choices if you’re looking for the best cookies in NYC, so let’s get into it!
From gooey, oozy cookies in NYC, to crispy and crunchy cookies in NYC – this list has something for everyone!
So, take a read and make a list! This is enough to satisfy anyone’s sweet tooth or cookies craving! Enjoy!
Let’s go! Here are the best cookies in NYC…
Levain
Levain Bakery remains one of the most famous bakeries in NYC, and its cookies are genuinely some of the best cookies in NYC.
Seriously, Levain is synonymous with the word “cookie”. Although you can grab these cookies from grocery stores, we highly recommend swinging by one of their many stores in the city.
These guys offer several flavors, but the Chocolate Chip Walnut is a classic which never disappoints. It’s jam packed full of chocolate chips, which leads to this gooey, oozy cookies from heaven!
This is a classic choice for the best cookies in NYC.
Tin Building by Jean-Georges
Next on ur list of the best cookies in NYC, it’s the Tin Building by Jean-Georges. This great little spot is located on the Lower East Side, on the newly redeveloped South Street Seaport.
This gorgeous boutique-style food hall is packed full of many delicious baked goods, and cookies happen to be something they do extremely well.
On our recent visit, we counted a total of 9 different cookies on sale, and they looked so deliciously perfect.
So, if you’re looking for vast cookie variety, yummy flavors, and a day exploring somewhere a little different in NYC, this is the choice for you when searching for the best cookies in NYC!
Clinton Street Baking Company
Our next suggestion for finding the best cookies in NYC, is Clinton St Baking Company.
Clinton St Baking Company is a popular choice on the Lower East Side, and it’s a frequent feature in ‘best baked goods’ lists of the city.
Most people know this place for their pastries and cakes, but we LOVE the cookies, and think they’re some of the best cookies in NYC.
Erin McKenna’s Bakery
Erin McKenna’s Bakery is next on our list of the best cookies in NYC.
Now, this place is known for serving the underserved. That means, if you’re allergic to common baking ingredients, if you’re vegan, or gluten free, you’re probably going to find something here to enjoy.
People with gluten, dairy, egg, and soy sensitivities all enjoy goodies from Erin McKenna’s Bakery, which is why we wanted to include it on our list!
It’s the cutest little location on the Lower East Side, and our favorite item has to be their cookies sandwiches (pictured below!).
Such a great pick for the best cookies in NYC!
Gooey on the Inside
Next on my list of the best cookies in NYC, it’s Gooey on the Inside.
True to its name, every cookie from Gooey on the Inside is gooey on the inside, so if you love those soft and squidgy cookies, then this is going to be a top choice for the best cookies in NYC!
Perfectly baked, chewy, and packed with yummy chocolate chips, these are certainly some of the best cookies in NYC. The owner is incredibly experimental, so expect to see interesting new additions every now and then.
Read more NYC food recommendations: 15 places to find the best pancakes in NYC!
Funny Face Bakery
Funny Face Bakery is an iconic cookie shop in NYC… As they create hilarious illustration-style cookies of memes and famous people.
We’re willing to bet you’ve seen these guys on Instagram or TikTok, even if you don’t realize it!
Alongside their funny meme cookies, they have some more classic flavors too. If you fancy something more traditional and classic, their gooey chocolate chip cookies are a must-try, and their amazing confetti cookie (a personal favorite of mine – and pictured below!).
Thick cookies, that are crunchy on the outside and gooey on the inside, these are what cookie dreams are made of!
Schmackary’s
If you’re looking for the best cookies in NYC, you can’t go wrong with our next suggestion. Are you heading to see a Broadway show?
Then be sure to pop into Schmackary’s before the curtain comes up! Schmackary’s cookies are packed with delicious quality ingredients, and they’re literally always the perfect combination of chewy and crunchy.
This place had only 10 flavors available when it first opened, but now it has an expansive menu of more than 75 flavors! Yep, you read that right.
What are you waiting for? Try one of the best cookies in NYC, we beg of you!
Read more NYC recommendations: 32 fun things to do in Soho, NYC
Ceci Cela NYC
Our next suggestion for the best cookies in NYC, is the amazing Ceci Cela.
This cute little patisserie feels homely and cute as a button, and they sell some pretty gorgeous cookies, that are amongst the best cookies in NYC.
Our favorites from Ceci Cela have to be the classic Chocolate chip cookies, or the marble cookies (both pictured below!).
William Greenberg Desserts
Next on our list of the best cookies in NYC, it’s an Upper East Side location called William Greenberg Desserts.
These guys are known for their black and white cookies, which are some of the most famous in NYC, and they are so delicious!
Read more NYC food inspiration: Top 50 best desserts in NYC
The cookie isn’t a gooey cookies, but it’s one of those classic New York cookies that you simply have to try whilst you’re there. Definitely a good choice for the best cookies in NYC!
Little Cupcake Bakeshop
Little Cupcake Bakeshop is located on Prince Street on the Lower East Side, and it’s one of the best places to get cookies in NYC.
This little bakeshop is absolutely adorable, and they have many different flavors of cookies to buy and try.
Our top pick? It’d have to be the Oatmeal Butterscotch cookie. It’s homely, sweet, tasty and comforting – and (especially when eaten warm) it’s the ultimate comfort cookie. Definitely one of the best cookies in NYC!
This is absolutely one of the best places to get cookies in NYC! You’ll love Little Cupcake Bakeshop, we know it.
Dominique Ansel Bakery
Dominique Ansel Bakery has long been known for its incredible bakes, but in our opinion, its cookies are next level and deserve their spot on this list of the best cookies in NYC.
Unlike some of the other places on our list, Dominique Ansel Bakery lets you have cookies and milk.
If you think it’s as simple as pouring yourself a glass of milk to have with some of the best cookies in NYC, you’d be wrong.
Dominique Ansel Bakery quite literally pours milk into their very own cookie cups, allowing you to experience milk and cookies in the most bougie way possible.
If you don’t fancy the milk-cup cookies, then their classic chocolate chip (pictured below) and so delicious. Chewy and crispy and not too sweet. On of the best cookies in NYC.
Breads Bakery
Located on 16th Street, Breads Bakery is an unassuming spot which just so happens to serve up some of the best cookies in NYC.
Sure, it may not be the loudest bakery in town, but it certainly bakes some of the most delicious desserts in the city.
If you often find yourself overwhelmed by choice, then you’ll be pleased to know that this bakery serves up only a limited variety of cookies. Butter Pecan, Granola, and Parmesan Cookies are all unique options which pack a punch.
These are definitely some of the best cookies in NYC.
Read more NYC food recommendations: 18 of the best bagels in NYC
Jacques Torres
At Jacques Torres, the cookies are as fancy as the store’s name, and that’s why they make our list of the best cookies in NYC.
Jacques Torres offers guests chocolates, macarons, and glorious hot chocolates. However, what sets this store apart from its competitors is its wonderful range of cookies.
The most popular choice is Jacques’ Famous Chocolate Chip Cookies (certainly one of the best cookies in NYC) filled with chunky chocolate and baked to perfection, these truly are the best cookies in NYC.
If you’re unable to have gluten, give their Gluten Free OMG Chocolate Cookies a try. We promise, they’re so good that you won’t even notice the lack of gluten!
Read more NYC food recommendations: Where to find the best macarons in NYC! Our top 12 locations.
Milk Bar
Next up on our list of the best cookies in NYC, it’s the amazing cookies served at Milk Bar. With multiple locations in the city, Milk Bar has garnered a reputation for having some of the best cookies in NYC.
What we love about Milk Bar is the fact that they move with the seasons.
Sure, they always have their usual chocolate chip cookies, but during the holidays, they create new cookies with peppermint, marshmallows, and more!
So, if you’re looking for something different during Christmas in New York this year, then be sure to get your hands on some of the best cookies in NYC! And try out their ice-cream whilst you’re there too!
Duane Park Patisserie
Next on our list of the best cookies in NYC, it’s Duane Park Patisserie.
If you’re stopping downtown or in the downtown / tribeca area, then this is going to be a must-visit location to try.
This little bakery is super adorable and looks like it has been transported from the streets of suburban Paris.
There are a few different cookie flavors you can pick from too, so great for those who love variety.
Molly’s Cupcakes
Next on our list of the best cookies in NYC, it’s a small place called Molly’s Cupcakes in Greenwich Village.
Molly’s Cupcakes are known mainly for their cupcakes (which are also incredible btw!) but we wanted to give their cookies a mention in this list, because they’re also so yummy.
Just take a look at the photo below from our recent visit! That is a 10/10 cookie if ever we saw one, and we can confirm it tasted as good as it looks!
It’s absolutely one of the best cookies in NYC, you have to try!
Mah-Ze-Dahr Bakery
Next on my list of the best cookies in NYC, it’s Mah-Ze-Dahr Bakery.
Everyone loves chocolate, and the folks at Mah-Ze-Dahr Bakery know that the best cookies in NYC should be filled with chocolatey goodness – which makes them a top choice for the best cookies in NYC.
The Chocolate Explosion at this store is a must-try; perfectly baked and topped with confectioners’ sugar, it’s a super-sweet treat that’s sure to keep you energized for hours.
It’s a great choice for the best cookies in NYC.
Read more NYC food recommendations: 50+ places for breakfast in NYC
Rocco’s
Next on our list of the best cookies in NYC, it’s Rocco’s in Greenwich Village.
This place is known for many baked goods, but it’s their M&Ms cookie that stole our hearts.
Look at how joyous, chocolatey and delicious this cookie is! The moment you see it on their shelves, you can’t help but order one!
It’s no wonder this place makes our list for the best cookies in NYC!
Chip City NYC
Chip City NYC is home to some of the best cookies in NYC, and they’ve long been a city favorite due to their incredibly gooey centers.
Over the years, the folks at Chip City NYC have perfected their recipe, and now fans can order several flavors which are all as good as the next.
For a religious cookie experience, we highly recommend checking out the Chocolate Peanut Butter or Nutella Sea Salt Flavors.
Both are super decadent and will keep you coming back for more! You’ll love this choice for the best cookies in NYC! Just look at the photo below – YUM!!
Kerber’s Farm
Kerber’s Farm is a gorgeous little bakery and cafe located in Greenwich Village, and it’s next on our list of the best cookies in NYC.
Their cookies are made from locally sourced ingredients and lovingly sourced products – so you know it’s going to taste great.
Their chocolate chunk cookies get our vote! They’re chunky, chewy, a little crunchy on the outside, and perfectly sweet.
Bonus suggestion: Whole Foods Market
There are loads of Whole Foods Markets around NYC, and in each one of them, you’ll find a pretty great spread of cookies on offer.
If you’re in a rush, and need to pick up some great-tasting cookies with your grocery shop, we actually think Wholefoods is a pretty great choice for some of the best cookies in NYC.
It’s a bit like a cookie pick’n’mix, check out our photo below of what’s on offer!
Hopefully this list of the best cookies in NYC has given you loads of inspiration!
As you can see, there are so many places to find the best cookies in NYC, and this city is jam-packed full of delicious cookies for trying! Why not make a day of it, and go on a cookie adventure?
You can head from place to place, scoring all these choices for the best cookies in NYC, and picking a favorite!
