The best cheesecake in NYC: 15 amazing places you NEED to try

June 6, 2021

Looking for the best cheesecake in NYC? If so, keep reading!

If you’ve got a craving for cheesecake and you’re looking for the best cheesecake in NYC – then you need to give this list a read! Here we’ve compiled a list of our top 15 places for the best cheesecake in NYC – perfect for when you’ve got a sweet tooth craving!

the best cheesecake in NYC

We all know NYC is known for being a foodie’s paradise. From the amazing pizza and steak places, to the epic donuts, chicken wings, breakfast places in NYC – this city has SO MUCH to choose from for people who love food! If cheesecake is on your list, then keep reading!

So let’s go… Here’s where you can find the best cheesecake in NYC!


Veniero’s Pasticceria & Café 

Let’s kick off this list of the best cheesecake in NYC – it’s Veniero’s Pasticceria & Café! The oldest spot in NYC for cheesecake is Veniero’s Pasticceria & Caffe. Having established itself in 1894 (yep, you read that right!), these guys have had over a century to perfect their various recipes.

Though their cannoli, biscotti and light bites are well worth sampling, it’s the cheesecake that really makes an impact at this Italian bakery. Said by some to be the best cheesecake in NYC, you’d be unwise to not try a slice at the very least…


Eileen’s Special Cheesecake

Since 1975, Eileen’s has been serving up the best cheesecake in NYC. Seriously, this wonderful cheesecake shop doesn’t mess around. With upwards of 20 flavors on their roster, you can plan a three-week trip to the city and still not taste them all.

However, we’d certainly be impressed if you managed to just order one at a time. What makes this place special (and what makes it worthy of the best cheesecake in NYC award) is the recipe. Eileen’s Special Cheesecake was created by Eileen Avenzzano over 40 years ago, and it has stood the test of time and continues to impress. 


Two Little Red Hens

If you want to settle in for a relaxed afternoon of catching up with a friend, then Two Little Red Hens is the perfect place to try. Serving up the best cheesecake in NYC (prepared the traditional New York way, in case you were interested!), this is a dessert-lover’s paradise.

The classic graham cracker crust at Two Little Red Hens is the perfect combination of soft and crunchy, and the filling to these cheesecakes are always to die for. Seriously, it’s easy to see why so many people think that this joint is home to the best cheesecake in NYC!


Junior’s

Although you may think that the name of this place inspires tiny portions and delicate meals, you’d be sorely mistaken! Junior’s is home to some of the best cheesecake in NYC, and although the cheesecakes here are simple, they are more flavorful than most. Made using simple ingredients that are staples for a reason, you won’t leave this Brooklyn-based eatery in a hurry. One slice? Two slices? The world is your oyster. Junior’s is great choice for the best cheesecake in NYC.


S&S Cheesecake

If you’re looking for the most glorious, fluffy cheesecake, then you’ll need to grab a slice of goodness from S & S Cheesecake. As you might assume from their cheesecake-focused name, the folks here know how to produce the best cheesecake in NYC.

Although it’s a bit of a trek from central Manhattan (this cheesecake eatery is in the Bronx), the cheesecake makes it well worth it. With a small menu full of classics, you won’t feel too overwhelmed either. You can either keep things classic with a New York Style Cheesecake, or get adventurous with their Pineapple cheesecake! Decisions, decisions. Whatever you choose, you’re sure to agree that it’s some of the best cheesecake in NYC.  


Pasticceria Rocco

Another fabulous Italian bakery that we love is Pasticceria Rocco, and you’ll be pleased to know that this place is also home to some of the best cheesecake in NYC! If you can’t get enough of a cheesecake’s crust, then you may want to steer clear of this one, as Pasticceria Rocco sacrifices the base of its cheesecakes to focus on its rich and creamy filling.

Don’t feel too bummed out though, the cheesecake filling here is so sensational, that it may be worth petitioning to have it removed for good! Another perfect choice for the best cheesecake in NYC!


Peacefood Café

It can be disappointing trying to find great desserts as a vegan. Sure, there are plenty of options out there, but you’re unlikely to encounter the best cheesecake in NYC when you can’t exactly eat the ingredients that make up the dish itself. Well, everything is about to change, folks! Peacefood Café have found a way to create the best cheesecake in NYC, and it just so happens to be vegan!

The strawberry cheesecake at Peacefood Café is to die for, and you can enjoy your dessert knowing that it’s completely free from egg and dairy. Score!


Mah-Ze-Dahr

If you’re looking for some of the best cheesecake in NYC but want to take a seat at a fancy bakery, then Mah-Ze-Dahr is your best bet. With slices of cheesecake that are as fancy as the bakery’s name, it doesn’t surprise us that Mah-Ze-Dahr continues to attract swathes of visitors every year.

Made with fragrant lemon oil and a delicious cookie crust, each bite of cheesecake here is as delectable as the last. If you can’t quite let go once you’ve left the city, these guys even deliver across the U.S.A! You can’t go wrong with this option for the best cheesecake in NYC.


Breads Bakery

For an Israeli touch, visit Breads Bakery for some of the best cheesecake in NYC. This wonderful little spot is on Union Square and offers up beautiful cheesecakes made by its Israeli baker. However, we should warn you – you can’t buy cheesecake by the slice here! Although the cheesecake here is some of the best cheesecake in NYC, it’s only available as whole cakes. So, you better come with a large appetite! 


Magnolia Bakery

Next on our list of the best cheesecake in NYC, it’s Magnolia Bakery. This place is one of my absolute top dessert places in NYC! You may have heard of Magnolia Bakery, as it serves up delicious cupcakes to the people of New York on the daily. However, you may not know that it also serves delectable cheesecakes! Known by many as the best cheesecake in NYC, you’ll find it hard to resist purchasing more than one slice at a time! With chocolate, pistachio, and caramel pecan only a handful of the flavors on offer, you’ll be spoiled for choice! 


Chikalicious Dessert Bar

If you’re looking for the most ridiculous, yet best cheesecake in NYC, then head down to Chikalicious Dessert Bar. Amongst other things, this spot serves up a Fromage Blanc Island Cheesecake. Although it’s nothing like a traditional cheesecake, it’s served with heavy cream and comes atop a bowl of ice. Bizarre, fluffy, and quite frankly delicious, this is a dish not to be missed. This is one of our favorite choices for the best cheesecake in NYC.


Dominique Ansel Bakery

This delicious bakery is home to some of the best cheesecake in NYC, and it offers one of the most unique takes on the dessert in the city. Dominique Ansel Bakery is one of the more upmarket places to grab the best cheesecake in NYC, and it is home to several delicious, soft cheesecakes that you can sink your teeth into. If you fancy something extra, pick up one of their famous Cronuts!


Keki Modern Cakes

Have you ever tried a Japanese cheesecake? If not, make sure you add this place to your list of options for the best cheesecake in NYC! These fluffy, souffle-like desserts are some of the best cheesecakes in NYC, and they’re certainly great for the ‘gram! Keki Modern Cakes are made with organic milk, fresh eggs, and the most delicious cream cheese around, so it’s unsurprising that these bouncy little wonders continue to entice New York’s tourists. 

They’re not like traditional cheesecake, but we guarantee this is one of the best cheesecake in NYC you’ll try!


La Cheesecake

Another amazing choice for the best cheesecake in NYC! La Cheesecake is located on 14th Avenue, and it regularly sees queues round the block. Although these guys serve up some incredible custom cakes, they are also home to some of the best cheesecake slices in NYC.

This cake store has been around for decades, and they truly use their experience to deliver the best product possible. The cheesecake here is creamy and chewy in equal measures, and it certainly qualifies as one of the best cheesecakes in NYC – if you can handle the lines of course! This is definitely one of the best cheesecake in NYC!


Little Pie Company

If you love freshly baked goods that taste as though they were made on site, then you’ll love the Little Pie Company. Home to some of the best cheesecake in NYC, every pie available here is freshly made. No nasties, no preservatives, and no-nonsense. Whether you like your cheesecake chocolatey or prefer to stick to what you know with a vanilla slice, you’re sure to fall head over heels in love with dessert at the Little Pie Company. You’ll love this option for the best cheesecake in NYC.


We hope this list of where to find the best cheesecake in NYC has been helpful!

There are so many great choices for where to find the best cheesecake in NYC! So when that next cheesecake craving hits – you know exactly where to find the best cheesecake in NYC.

You Might Also Like

No Comments

Leave a Reply