Food, New York, NYC, USA

The Best Oysters in NYC… 18 Amazing Restaurants & Bars You Need to Visit!

September 23, 2022

If you’re craving the best Oysters in NYC, this list should give you loads of locations to try!

If you’ve been searching for the best oysters in NYC, then look no further! This is our ultimate list of where to find the best oysters in NYC!

NYC is a bit of a hotspot for amazing oyster restaurants… And if you didn’t already know, NYC had another nickname before “The Big Apple”. In fact, it was once called “The Big Oyster”!

Some of the best oysters in NYC can be found in restaurants dating way back to those times, and you’ll find out all about them on this list!

So, anyway, let’s get into our list of where to find the best oysters in NYC!


Here are our favorite picks for the best oysters in NYC…


Ama Raw Bar West Village

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/amarawbar/

Ama Raw Bar West Village is our first suggestion for where to find the best oysters in NYC. This place has some amazing online reviews, rarely scoring less than 4.8 / 5.

It’s one of the top places to try the best oysters in NYC, and it’s Asian-inspired, which means you’ll find unique flavors and combinations you may not get elsewhere.

Oh, and did we mention their famous $1 oyster happy hours? It’s something you have to check out! Oysters have never been more delicious or affordable!

This is such a great choice for sampling some of the best oysters in NYC, and we know you’ll love it.

Read more NYC food recommendations: Top 15 upscale restaurants in NYC


Mermaid Oyster Bar

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/themermaidnyc/

Our next suggestion for where to find the best oysters in NYC, is Mermaid Oyster Bar, on MacDougal St.

This place is an upscale-casual place, serving up some of the best seafood in the city.

There’s a lovely coastal vibe here, and you’ll find some of the best oysters in NYC being served up for happy customers! These guys also have an oyster happy hour, you’ll be relived to hear!

This is a wonderful pick for where to find the best oysters in NYC, and it’s a favorite with locals and tourists!


Grand Central Oyster Bar

Image credit: https://www.oysterbarny.com/

The Grand Central Oyster Bar is next on our list of places to find the best oysters in NYC. If you want to eat somewhere iconic, then this is a great place to eat the best oysters in NYC!

Located inside the amazing, beautiful, Grand Central Station – you can’t get more New York City than this! It’s busy, bustling and wonderful!

You’ll find lots of delicious food here, from raw oysters, pan roasts & chowders – so plenty of things to try alongside the best oysters in NYC!

Read more about NYC dining: Top 15 best French restaurants in NYC


Crave Fishbar

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/cravefishbar/

Next on our list of where to find the best oysters in NYC, it’s Crave Fishbar. We love Crave Fishbar, as they offer big oyster portions and brunch options too!

Another lovely thing about this oyster place in NYC? It’s New York City’s first 100% sustainable seafood restaurant! Which is a really wonderful and unique reason to visit this restaurant!

Alongside some of the best oysters in NYC, this place also serves up local seafood, and fresh local catches!

Read more about NYC food: Top 20 places to eat alone in NYC


Pearl Oyster Bar NYC

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/pearloysterbarnyc/

Next on our list of the best oysters in NYC, it’s Pearl Oyster Bar. This cozy and romantic restaurant is a great choice when searching for the best oysters in NYC.

Pearl Oyster Bar actually began as a tiny 22-seat bar, with just one single table! But it doubled in size when it became so popular and frequented by locals.

Rebecca Charles is the founder and chef here, and her love for seafood and traditional oyster techniques really shines through.

This is an amazing choice for the best oysters in NYC, and it’s full of tradition and history.

Read more about NYC food: Where to find the best lobsters in NYC!


Cull & Pistol

Image credit: https://www.cullandpistol.com/

Next on our list of the best oysters in NYC, it’s Cull & Pistol!

There’s a great oyster happy hour here, from 4pm – 6pm every Monday to Friday. During the happy hour you’ll get 50% off their delicious oysters!

You’ll find some wonderful seafood here, alongside the oysters, such as traditional clam chowder, lobster rolls and lobster bake!

Oh, and the desserts are great too, you have to try their amazing banana pudding!

Read more NYC recommendations: 18 best happy hours on the upper west side!


Grand Banks Oyster Bar

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/grandbanksnyc/

Now, if you want to eat some of the best oysters in NYC, with some of the best views in NYC – then this next location is for you!

Grand Banks Oyster Bar is one of the most ‘wow’ locations in the city to enjoy the best oysters in NYC!

This is one of those NYC dining experiences that everyone has to try at least once! In fact, Grand Banks isn’t on land – it’s aboard the historic wooden schooner, Sherman Zwicker!

Talk about an authentic oyster experience! Eat the best oysters in NYC, on the waves!


Upstate craft beer & oyster bar

Next on our list of places to find the best oysters in NYC, it’s the Upstate craft beer & oyster bar. This cozy spot in the Ukrainian Village is such a gorgeous spot!

This is a classic choice for trying some of the best oysters in NYC, and we love the setting too. It’s cozy, and intimate, and feels like a lovely place to relax for the evening!

If you’re looking for some of the best oysters in NYC in a place that has both character and charm, this is it!


Docks Oyster Bar NYC

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/docksoysterbar/

Our next suggestion for the best oysters in NYC, is the Docks Oyster Bar NYC. This is another oyster place in NYC known for it’s amazing happy hour!

This art-deco-styled restaurant is beautiful inside and feels so very New York. The energy and vibe here is lively and fun, and we think you’ll love it.

This place is an elegant choice for the best oysters in NYC, and it’s an ideal pick for a date night or special occasion!

Read more NYC food recommendations: 50 amazing places to grab breakfast in NYC


Sel Rrose

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/selrrose/

Located right by Bowery subway station, you’ll find our next pick for the best oysters in NYC. Sel Rrose is a sophisticated and chic spot to enjoy some of the best oysters in NYC!

This place is an intimate setting, and serves up some french-inspired dishes, alongside their famous oysters!

They also have some wonderful cocktails here, which we recommend trying as well as their amazing oysters! On a sunny evening, we recommend trying their Lower East Sunset cocktail!

Read more NYC food inspiration: 12 EPIC food challenges in NYC!


The Clam

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/theclamnyc/

Next on our list of places to find the best oysters in NYC, it’s The Clam! This cute and cozy neighborhood bar is a classic pick for the best oysters in NYC!

Chef Mike Price is at the wheel here, and his ever-evolving menu means that you’ll always be eating seafood that is fresh and seasonal, celebrating gorgeous fresh ingredients.

There is also a beautifully curated wine list to try here too, which highlights lots of stunning wine producers from all around the world.

This is a cozy spot in the West Village that is also sophisticated, and that’s a magical mix. It’s a great choice for trying some of the best oysters in NYC.


Flex Mussels

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/flexmussels/

Flex Mussels is our next suggestion for where to find the best oysters in NYC! Flex Mussels is a great choice, and such a fun venue to eat in.

As the name suggests here, it’s not just some of the best oysters in NYC they serve up! It’s also some of the best mussels too!

Their seafood is packed full of flavor, and their menu is sophisticated yet fun, which is why this place makes our list of the best oysters in NYC!

We think you’re going to love it here!


Bait & Hook NYC

Image credit: https://baitandhookny.com/

Next up on our list of the best oysters in NYC, it’s Bait & Hook NYC. This is a casual, low-key restaurant, and it’s a great place for enjoying some of the best oysters in NYC.

The vibe here is chilled, with a lovely snug setting, with cute beach accents amongst the decor.

We love their cocktail list too, so this is a great location if you fancy mixing your oysters with some fun cocktails too!

This is the kind of place we’d love to spend a cozy evening, enjoying their amazing food and some great company! And (of course) some of the best oysters in NYC.


Sagaponack NYC

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/sagavibes/

Located near the iconic Flat Iron Building, our next suggestion for the best oysters in NYC, is Sagaponack NYC.

Sagaponack’s big focus is always on the quality of their ingredients, which is why we so confidently put them on our list of the best oysters in NYC.

Another reason to love Sagaponack? The cocktail menu is delicious, and each drink is as thoughtfully planned as their food plates.

We really recommend this place, it’s fantastic, welcoming, and (obviously) they serve up some of the best oysters in NYC.


Maison Premiere

Image credit: https://maisonpremiere.com/

Maison Premiere is next on our list of the best oysters in NYC, that you simply have to try!

You’ll find oysters, seafood and super tasty cocktails at this New Orleans-inspired restaurant. With all of that to enjoy, you can see why this place made our list of the best oysters in NYC.

This place has an old-worldly feel to it, and its charm and coziness is off the scales! It would be a gorgeous location for a special date night.

This is just a perfect place for the best oysters in NYC.


ZZ’s Clam Bar

ZZ’s Clam Bar is our next suggestion for where to find the best oysters in NYC. This is a tiny little place, offering up oysters and a raw bar in the heart of New York.

This place is one of those upscale, quirky locations in the city, that anyone searching for a more unique oyster experience will adore.

It’s elegant and exclusive here, with a definite fine-dining vibe – but it’s equally welcoming too once you’re seated. It’s an ideal place to enjoy some of the best oysters in NYC.

Read more about visiting NYC at Christmas: What restaurants are open on Christmas Day in NYC?


Sea Fire Grill

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/theseafiregrill/

Our next suggestion for finding the oysters in NYC, is to visit Sea Fire Grill in Midtown.

This is a great upscale choice for eating some of the best posters in NYC, and you’ll also find a complex and beautiful seafood menu to enjoy too.

Sea Fire Grill serve up locally sourced seafood (which we love) and their elegant dining rooms also feature a roaring fireplace, which makes it an ideal choice for romantic date nights!

This is a great choice for eating some of the best oysters in NYC, and we think you’ll love it.


Grey Lady NYC

Image credit: https://www.greyladynyc.com/space

And finally, on our list of the best oysters in NYC, it’s Grey Lady NYC. Thisis a classic pick for the best oysters in NYC, and we think you’ll love it!

Whilst we really recommend heading here on a weekend to enjoy their seafood brunch (it’s amazing), the all-week menu is also brilliant and delicious.

The food here is so tasty, and we love the vibe too.

Read more NYC food recommendations: 15 best Japanese restaurants in NYC


We hope this list of places to find the best oysters in NYC has given you loads of ideas!

Wherever you choose to visit for the best oysters in NYC, we know you’ll love it.

NYC is one of the best cities in the world for eating oysters, so it’s no wonder our list of the best oysters in NYC has so many choices!

You Might Also Like