The Best Lobsters in NYC: 14 Restaurants You Have to Try!

July 26, 2021

Searching for the best lobsters in NYC? If so, keep reading for our suggestions of amazing lobster restaurants in NYC!

If you enjoy the finer things in life, chances are you LOVE Lobster. If you’re currently in NYC and you’re searching for the best lobsters in NYC and the best lobster restaurants in NYC – then keep reading!

We’ve put together our list of the best lobsters in NYC, so you know exactly where to go when you want delicious lobster for dinner in NYC. Not all our recommendations for the best lobsters in NYC are ‘specialist’ lobster places, but pon their menus you’ll find an amazing lobster dish (or many!) on offer!

Anyway, let’s get into it!


Here are our recommendations for the best lobsters in NYC!


Nick’s Lobster Fish Market

If you happen to be on the hunt for the best lobsters in NYC, then head to Nick’s Lobster Fish Market. This Brooklyn-based eatery is a classic pick for tourists, and it features a 300-gallon tank that diners can choose their lobsters from.

It’s worth noting that despite serving some of the best lobsters in NYC, Nick’s is on the pricey side. Realistically, that’s to be expected from any lobster dish. However, we thought we’d give you a fair warning before you rock up with a $10 bill and expect a full dining experience!

The service here is always excellent, and Nick’s is conveniently located in the heart of Brooklyn for those who want to take a break from sightseeing. If you fancy taking some seafood home, then be sure to visit their onsite fish market. Providing all the gorgeous seafood that you’ll need to whip up restaurant-quality food at home, this place is deserving of a place on our list of the best lobsters in NYC. 


Luke’s Lobster

Luke’s Lobster is next on our list of the best lobsters in NYC. It’s a family-owned business that originally started as a lobster roll shack in the heart of New York City. Since then, the business has expanded to provide branded grocery items that can be purchased across the country! Stretching as far as Japan and Singapore, these guys are truly going global.

If you’d like to try the best lobsters in NYC, then be sure to visit one of their many shacks. Prices here aren’t extortionate, and each entrée will probably set you back around $15. One of the standout items on the menu is the lobster roll (it is the dish that started Luke’s, after all!).

Read more NYC food inspiration: Top 50 best desserts in NYC

Perfectly tender and packed with flavor, each dish here features the best lobsters in NYC. Although you can dine inside, you might struggle to find a table. So, we highly recommend grabbing your food to go and taking a walk! 


Delmonico’s

Fancy lobster is the name of the game at Delmonico’s. Now, these guys don’t exclusively serve lobster dishes, but the best lobsters in NYC can be found here. If you’re not sure of what to order, then we’ll help you out.

The Lobster Newberg is a dish that is ordered frequently by patrons, and it’s easy to see why. Featuring gorgeously tender lobster, cream, brandy and eggs, this indulgent dish will have you clamoring for seconds. If you’re wondering why Delmonico’s is home to the best lobsters in NYC, we’ll fill you in.

Read more NYC food inspiration: The best pizza in Times Square (6 places to try!)

It’s all about flavor and seasonal switch-ups. The Lobster Newberg gets changed up each season, so if you’re a frequent visitor to the city, be sure to experience this dish’s regular transformation. 


Perry St.

Not only is Perry St. a stunning restaurant, but it’s home to the best lobsters in NYC! You’ve probably tried a Lobster Thermidor before, but you’re unlikely to have tried a Thermidor that lives up to Perry St’s. Okay, so this dish isn’t for the calorie conscious; it’s swimming in rich cream and egg yolks.

What’s more, you get a generous layer of Gruyere cheese when you order this bad boy too. However, life is for the living, so why not branch out and try the best lobsters in NYC? However, despite nodding to the traditional dish, Perry St doesn’t serve the best lobsters in NYC in your average way.

Read more NYC food inspiration: The best cake shops in NYC (12 places you need to try!)

These guys combine regular Thermidor flavors with interesting Asian influences like spicy Thai red chilis! It’s absolutely one of the best lobsters in NYC, so give it a try!


Burger and Lobster

Next on our list of the best lobsters in NYC, it’s Burger and Lobster. This is a classic choice for the best lobster in NYC, especially if you’re prone to a little bit of surf and turf!

Their Bryant Park location is in the heart of Midtown Manhattan, so it’s a great choice if you happen to be stopping around the midtown location too – you’ll be able to easily walk there (and then walk it off afterwards too!). As the name suggests – you’ll be able to find both burgers and lobsters here – which makes this a great choice for the best lobsters in NYC!


The Lobster Place @ Chelsea Market

Our next suggestion for the best lobster in NYC, is The Lobster Place in Chelsea Market. Chelsea Market is an absolute must-visit for any foodies in the city, and you’ll find so much here (not just lobsters!).

But what makes this one of the best lobsters in NYC? Well, this place serves up classic lobster dishes, and classic flavors too. It’s one of the food locations in the city that you simply have to visit. Definitely one of the best lobsters in NYC – so don’t miss it!


Pearl Oyster Bar

Pearl Oyster Bar is ideal for those looking for the best lobsters in NYC that are cooked well and dished out in hearty portions! If you do pay Pearl Oyster Bar a visit, be sure to order the famous lobster roll. It’s perfectly seasoned and prepared traditionally, so you can expect a flavor sensation with each bite.

Read more about NYC food: Top 12 best places to eat in Little Italy, NYC

If you fancy a side dish, why not try the smoked clam soup? Every dish here is delectable, and you may as well try something new while you sample the best lobsters in NYC! 

Go on, branch out!


Olmsted

Not only does Olmsted serve some of the most gorgeous desserts in NYC, but they also have the best lobsters in NYC too! This is another spot where the Lobster Thermidor takes center stage.

Read more NYC food inspiration: Where to find the best wings in NYC

Although there are other gorgeous items on the menu at Olmsted (like the homemade frozen yogurt that you’ll find on our list of the best desserts in NYC), the Lobster Thermidor takes the cake. Featuring classic ingredients like brandy and Gruyere cheese, the lobsters in this Thermidor are absolutely the best lobsters in NYC.

If the creamy sauce and perfectly cooked lobster wasn’t enough to entice you, the fact that this is one of the more reasonably priced best lobsters in NYC might! 


Sparks Steak House

OK, our next suggestion for the best lobster in NYC, is the Sparks Steak House. We know the name implies this place specialises more in steak and seafood – but all good steakhouses will offer some delicious seafood too! Sparks Steak House offers up a classically delicious lobster dish, that we know you’ll find scrumptious.

Definitely head to this great midtown restaurant for some of the best lobsters in NYC!


Urban Lobster

If you’re searching for the best lobsters in NYC, then be sure to pay Urban Lobster a visit. This place features several of the best lobsters in NYC, with live lobster, lobster tails, and lobster meat all up for sale.

Read more NYC food inspiration: The best deli in NYC – 11 places you need to try!

That’s for those who want to purchase the best lobsters in NYC to devour at home, of course! If you’d like to dine in and have your lobster prepped for you, then you can expect high-quality dishes, great service, and some excellent side dishes to enjoy alongside your meal.

The prices aren’t too bad either – expect to pain up to $30 for a dish depending on what you order. 


Ed’s Lobster Bar

We love Ed’s lobster bar. Not only does it serve the best lobsters in NYC, but it’s got a great atmosphere. Now, before we delve into the menu items at Ed’s, we thought we’d give you fair warning of this restaurant’s pricing. It’s high. Sure, the dishes are delicious, but they come at a price!

As this place specializes in lobster dishes though, you can expect excellent food. Whether you fancy classic grilled lobster or prefer to bite into a hearty lobster sandwich, you’ll find the best lobsters in NYC at Ed’s.  


The Grill

The Grill is a popular restaurant for many reasons, but it’s the best lobsters in NYC that keep diners coming back. If you’re looking for a Lobster Newberg with a twist, then The Grill is the place to be. Located in Midtown East, this restaurant is always packed to the rafters.

For that reason (and the fact that they serve the best lobsters in NYC!), we highly advise reserving a table in advance. The Lobster Newberg is served with the shell on, so you really get the full lobster-eating experience here. Although you will taste cream in this dish, what makes the largest impact is the tomato flavor.

Mixing perfectly with the rich natural flavor of the lobster, it’s a melt-in-your-mouth dish that shouldn’t be missed. 


ZAVO

Bougie and beautiful, ZAVO is one of those restaurants that is worth the visit for the ambience alone. If the atmosphere doesn’t grab you, then the best lobsters in NYC sure will. Sure, you may be left slightly out of pocket after a visit to ZAVO, but this restaurant is well worth the price tag.

Read more NYC food inspiration: 50 amazing breakfast places in NYC

The Lobster Thermidor here features the best lobsters in NYC and comes in at a whopping two pounds in weight. Featuring a glorious cognac cream sauce and wild mushrooms, this is a rather unique Thermidor that will please you with every bite. Don’t just take our word for it of course – get booking to experience the best lobsters in NYC for yourself! 


Hopefully this list of the best lobsters in NYC has given you loads of inspiration!


As you can see, there are lots of amazing locations in the city to experience some of the best lobsters in NYC. We hope this list has given you loads of ideas for where to visit for the best lobsters in NYC, we know you’ll love them all!

You Might Also Like