Food, New York, NYC, Travel Food, USA

What is The Best Bakery in NYC? Here’s Our Top 10 Choices!

March 29, 2022

Are you looking got the best bakery in NYC? If so, hopefully, this list of New York bakeries will give you lots of amazing locations to try!

If you’ve got a sweet tooth, you might be looking for the best bakery in NYC!

Well, if that sounds like you, then this list is going to fill you with plenty of ideas and inspiration when searching for the perfect New York bakery.

So whether you’re looking for the best bakery in NYC for a sweet breakfast or just a sweet after-dinner treat, we know you’re going to find somewhere perfect on this list of the best bakery in NYC.

So let’s get into it and find the best New York bakery!


So, what is the best bakery in NYC? Let’s find out!


Dominique Ansel Bakery

Image credit: https://www.dominiqueanselny.com/

If you’re looking for the best bakery in NYC, you really can’t go wrong with Dominique Ansel Bakery.

Not only is this bakery in NYC run by a highly-skilled pastry chef, but it seamlessly blends American and French techniques for an experience unlike any other New York bakery.

There’s so much to love about this New York bakery, but we’d say the must-try items are the infamous cronut, the caramelized croissants, and the oh-so-delicate madeleines.

Each one baked to perfection, you’ll struggle to stop at just one. No wonder this place is considered the best bakery in NYC.

If you’d prefer something a touch more unique, why not try the milk shot glasses? Literally made from chocolate chip cookies, each ‘glass’ is filled with fresh milk and downed like a shot. It’s a great bakery in NYC, so you have to try it!

Innovative, bizarre, and completely delicious, it’s a sweet-treat experience that you need to try at least once. Hey, there’s a reason this place is considered the best bakery in NYC!


Mah-Ze-Dahr New York Bakery

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/mahzedahrbakery/

Another great choice for the best bakery in NYC, is Mah-Ze-Dahr Bakery. Pronouncing it may be a bit of a mouthful, but Mah-Ze-Dahr Bakery remains the best bakery in NYC.

Run by pastry chef Umber Ahmad and his wife, this quaint New York bakery has been pleasing sweet-toothed New Yorkers since its inception in 2014.

Typically seeing queues out the door, it’s unsurprising that Ahmad was once a semi-finalist for a James Beard Award!

If you don’t know what this is, it’s a big deal. It’s definitely one of the top choices if you’re looking for a bakery in NYC.

Serving up delicious sponge cakes, cheesecakes, cookies, brioche donuts, and everything in-between, this quaint bakery in NYC remains a favorite among locals and tourists alike.

Oh, just a quick heads up – we recommend ordering more than one thing and popping the leftovers in your bag.

Keeping well for a day or so, you’ll be able to refuel during the day with a dark chocolate brownie or brioche morning bun! Talk about delish. This is an amazing New York bakery.

Read more NYC food recommendations: Where to find the best bagels in NYC


New York bakery: Ovenly

Image credit: https://oven.ly/

If you’re looking for a bakery in NYC, Ovenly is amazing.

Opened by Erin Patinkin and Agatha Kulaga, Ovenly is a bakery in NYC that is small but mighty. Although the café itself has only 13 seats, you can grab an incredible bake to go or even get a delivery to your door!

Although this place started its life as a wholesale bakery in NYC, it opened its first retail location a few years ago and has been thriving.

If you’ve never been to this bakery in NYC before, we suggest you order the Brooklyn Blackout Cake. Made with salted chocolate pudding and a generous volume of Brooklyn Brewery beer, it’s the booziest pick-me-up in the city. It’s a New York bakery you don’t want to miss!

Should you be keeping your mornings alcohol-free, opt for the Carrot Ginger Cake, chewy cookies, or Blueberry Cornflake Muffin. Each boasting a different flavor profile, you’re sure to return for more at this bakery in NYC!

Read more about NYC dining: Top 15 best French restaurants in NYC


Buttercup Bakeshop

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/buttercupbakeshop/

If you’re looking for a ridiculously decadent bakery in NYC, consider the search over with Buttercup Bakeshop.

Serving up perfectly gooey variations of cupcakes, bars, puddings, and pies, this incredible bakery in NYC is built for foodies. It’s a fantastic New York bakery.

Everything on the menu is delicious, but we’d say the Campfire S’mores Bar and the Apple Pie A-La-Mode cupcake are both must-try items. This is an amazing bakery in NYC.

With a couple of locations littered across the city, you can get your sweet fix from this bakery in NYC in Brooklyn or Manhattan – phew!

Before we forget, the Assorted Mini Cupcakes are an excellent choice for families with kids or anyone who struggles to decide on what sweet treat they’d like to try.

Offering a selection of chocolate, vanilla, and red velvet delights, they’re bound to be demolished in record time! A brilliant choice of New York bakery.

Read more about NYC food: The best brunch in NYC – 15 places to try!


Bakery in NYC: Levain

Image credit: https://levainbakery.com/

Best known for their chewy cookies and delectable cakes, Levain is a bakery in NYC with a reputation that precedes it! It’s another amazing choice for bakeries in NYC!

The perfect cookie can be difficult to describe, but we’ve all seen one. Golden-brown on the outside, soft in the center, and packed with chocolate chips, finding the ideal chocolate chip cookie sometimes feels like a pipe dream – but not with Levain! This bakery in NYC is sooo delicious!

This bakery in NYC consistently produces the best cookies in the Big Apple, and there are only five cookies to choose from.

Although this may sound like a bad thing, we feel that a carefully curated list is always the way to go when it comes to quality control.

If you’re not sure what to pick, the Original Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie and the Oatmeal Raisin are great places to start! This is a wonderful bakery in NYC. This is a great New York bakery.

Read more NYC food inspiration: 12 EPIC food challenges in NYC!


Supermoon Bakehouse

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/supermoonbakehouse/

If you’re on the hunt for a bakery in NYC that serves up Instagrammable treats, you’ll simply adore Supermoon Bakehouse. 

This bakery in NYC serves up plenty of cakes and cookies, but it’s their famous “cruffin” that put them on the map. This is such a wonderful New York bakery.

As you might expect from its name, the cruffin combines a croissant and a muffin for a flakey treat that’s completely morish.

Several flavors are worth trying at this bakery in NYC, but we’d say the Dual-Core Cruffin made with peanut butter and jelly is a slam dunk. Made with a Peanut Butter Crème Pâtissière and lashings of strawberry jam, it’s the most decadent thing on their menu.

Oh, and did we mention it’s topped with extra peanut brittle for a delightful crunch? Perfect. This is an incredible bakery in NYC. Another great New York bakery you’ll want to try!

Read more NYC food recommendations: 20 of the best cheap lunches in NYC


Magnolia Bakery

Image credit: https://www.magnoliabakery.com/

Magnolia Bakery has been a staple bakery in NYC for years.

Best known for its classic American baked goods and world-famous desserts, this bakery in NYC is always packed with hungry locals and tourists alike.

What sets this bakery in NYC apart from the competition is its made-from-scratch promise.

Sure, many NYC bakeries serve fresh baked goods, but they’re typically made using pre-mixes or brought out from the freezer – no bueno. Don’t miss this New York bakery!

They are most famous for their cupcakes (Reese’s and M&M cupcakes anyone?!), but the Banana Pudding, cheesecakes, and brownie bars are equally delicious.

Whatever you order from this bakery in NYC, you’re unlikely to be disappointed! It’s a top bakery in NYC.

Read more NYC food recommendations: 15 amazing places to find cheesecake in NYC


New York bakery: Angelina Bakery

Image credit: https://angelinabakery.com/

Next on our list of the top bakery in NYC, it’s Angelina Bakery.

If you’re on the hunt for a bakery in NYC that sells picture-perfect desserts, flakey croissants, and delicate tarts, then you’ve come to the right place at Angelina Bakery.

Best known for their Italian cannoli tarts, you can quite literally pop 5 or 6 of these bad boys without batting an eyelid. This is such a wonderful bakery in NYC.

If you’d like something more Americanized, why not check out their amazing chocolate chip cookies or enormous muffins?

Handcrafted to perfection using the finest authentic ingredients and old-school techniques, every bite promises to be a total taste sensation! Another wonderful New York bakery to try out!

Read more NYC food recommendations: 50 amazing places to grab breakfast in NYC


Bakery in NYC: Daily Provisions

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/dailyprov/

Sometimes, the best bakery in NYC is an unassuming local spot that has gained a cult following over the years. If you’re wondering which wonderful bakery in NYC fits this description, it’s Daily Provisions!

This New York bakery serve plenty of sweet and sugary goodies, their bestselling items are breakfast sandwiches.

Packed with bacon, egg, cheese, smoked salmon, and several other classic toppings, you can build your ideal hunger-buster in minutes. You’re going to love this New York bakery!

If the food wasn’t enough to convince you to stop by this bakery in NYC, we recommend sampling a cup of their strong coffee.

Gorgeously roasted and packed with flavor, it’ll put a spring in your step for a day of sightseeing!

Read more NYC food recommendations: Where to find the best pancakes in NYC


Veniero’s Pasticceria and Caffe

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/venierospastry/

It’s been an interesting journey trying to find the best bakery in NYC, but we couldn’t finish our list without including Veniero’s Pasticceria and Caffe!

Believe it or not, this New York bakery has been operating since 1894. This makes it one of the oldest bakeries in NYC!

Depending on your taste, you can grab a quick cup of Joe and a biscotti or settle in for a slice of cake. If you’re feeling super decadent, why not spring for a slice of cheesecake? An amazing bakery in NYC!

Made the classic New York way, you’ll be going back for seconds (or perhaps thirds!) at this bakery in NYC!

Read more about NYC shopping: Top 14 grocery stores in NYC


Hopefully you’re excited to try these bakeries in NYC!

Hopefully, our list of the best bakeries in NYC has given you plenty of ideas for places to try! Which bakery in NYC will you visit first? Let us know!

Read more about visiting NYC: 22 romantic anniversary ideas in NYC

Read more NYC food recommendations: Where to find the best hot chocolate in NYC20 locations!

You Might Also Like