The best cake shops in NYC! 12 Amazing places you NEED to try!

July 26, 2021

Are you looking for the best cake shops in NYC? If so, keep reading!

If you’ve got a craving for cake, you might be looking for the best cake shops in NYC!

There are so many amazing cake shops in NYC (so many to choose from!) so it can be tricky knowing which particular ones are the best cake shops in NYC. Let’s be honest, who has got time to waste on below-average cake? If you’ve got a craving for cake, then you’ll want the best cake shops in NYC… and nothing less!

So, with that in mind, we’ve put together a list of our favorite cake shops in NYC, which we know you’re going to LOVE! So let’s get into it!

the best cake shops in NYC

The best cake shops in NYC…


Magnolia Bakery

The top spot on our list of the best cake shops in NYC just had to go to Magnolia Bakery. This bakery has long been considered one of the best places to visit for delicious cakes. Whether you fancy the famous German Chocolate Layer Cake or a tiny cupcake, you’ll be able to find it at Magnolia Bakery! 

However, it’s not just the cakes that keep people coming back, it’s the famous banana pudding. Perfectly balancing tart and sweet flavors, this unique pudding is one of the best desserts in NYC. So, if you’re on the hunt for the best cake shops in NYC that happen to feature a signature dish, then you’ve hit the motherlode here. 


Ladybird Bakery

The Ladybird Bakery is one of the best cake shops in NYC for those who like things done the traditional way. The cakes here are fluffy and perfectly baked and come in flavors that please the masses.

We’re talking gooey chocolate, light vanilla, and some of the best red velvet cupcakes you’ll ever try! The cakes here aren’t outlandish, but they’re flavorful and delicate. You’ll never find dry sponge or congealed frosting at Ladybird Bakery – only the freshest, cutest cakes in NYC at this choice for the best cake shops in NYC.

Read more NYC food inspiration: Top 50 best desserts in NYC

If you’re looking for something slightly different, you can also try their pies and tarts. Despite being one of the best cake shops in NYC, these guys also have a penchant for pastry too! Don’t believe us? Try these goodies for yourself. 


City Cakes

Okay, so it’s probably no surprise that City Cakes has made its way onto our list of the best cake shops in NYC. Realistically, how could it not?! The cakes at City Cakes are incredibly creative, so they’re the place to visit for birthday cakes.

Although this isn’t a spot to visit for purchasing cakes on a whim, this is one of the best cake shops in NYC for New Yorkers who are looking to wow guests at their next big bash. It doesn’t matter how crazy your cake dreams are, City Cakes can make it happen.

However, you need to be aware that a custom design comes at a hefty price. You need to believe us though; the result is more than worth the investment! Another amazing choice for the best cake shops in NYC.


Bon Vivant New York

Bougie, beautiful miniature cakes can be found at Bon Vivant New York. If you’re looking for one of the best cake shops in NYC that just screams luxury, then this place has got your back. The cakes and petit fours at Bon Vivant are delectable, but they’re also stunning.

They’re so stunning in fact, that you may not want to eat them at all! Each tiny cake is decorated with an ornate flower design, and you can order them in batches of different colors if you’re looking to spice things up. You can ask for a custom selection of cakes for any event. You definitely won’t want to miss this place for your best cake shops in NYC list!

Just be sure to call ahead to avoid disappointment. This is one of the best cake shops in NYC after all, so expect to give plenty of notice. 


Best cake shops in NYC: Soma Cakes

Another one of the best cake shops in NYC is Soma Cakes. Founded in Brooklyn by Hiroyo Ruiz, this company has long believed that all cakes should be beautiful. Ruiz worked under the famous pastry chef Eric Bedoucha and carried the knowledge she learned into her own blossoming business.

With incredible attention to detail and a genuine love for cake decorating, it’s unsurprising that Ruiz’s business is one of the best cake shops in NYC! The cakes here are all custom, so you’ll need to place an order far enough in advance to avoid disappointment.

On average, the recommended time for booking in for tastings at the best cake shops in NYC is 3 weeks ahead of time, so don’t miss out! If you’re not sure what flavor you’re after, you can book in a cake tasting for $45. Money well spent if we do say so ourselves…


Eileen’s Special Cheesecake

Eileen’s Special Cheesecake is next on our list of the best cake shops in NYC. It almost always features on ‘best of’ dessert lists, so it’s unsurprising that we consider it to be one of the best cake shops in NYC. It may not serve up classic sponge cakes, but the cheesecakes at Eileen’s are some of the finest in the city. Perfectly creamy and traditional, these cakes never disappoint. 

Read more NYC food inspiration: Where to find the best cheesecake in NYC – 15 places to try!

The Original cheesecake is always a winner, but if you’re looking for something different, why not sample the Salted Caramel or S’mores cheesecakes? They’re all equally delicious, so you’re unlikely to make the wrong choice! This is one of the best cake shops in NYC, and you won’t want to miss it!


Ovenly

A list of the best cake shops in NYC just isn’t complete without Ovenly. It’s almost difficult to believe how perfect these cakes are. Perfectly decorated without a speck of frosting out of place, these are the cakes to purchase if you’re looking to impress your friends.

If you’re looking for the standout cakes here, then be sure to try out the Brooklyn Blackout Cake and the Lemon Lavender Cake. Both are very different but pack an equal punch of deliciousness. However, it’s not just the cakes themselves that makes Ovenly one of the best cake shops in NYC – it’s their amazing mission.

Founded and led by women, Ovenly aims to employ LGBTQ+ members and formerly incarcerated individuals. Believing that everyone deserves equal opportunities (and a generous slice of cake), Ovenly is an impressive enterprise that we feel deserves a spot on our list of the best cake shops in NYC. Keep fighting the good fight, Ovenly! 


Butter & Scotch

Next on our list of the best cake shops in NYC, it’s Butter & Scotch. Pies, cookies, and cakes are the name of the game at Butter & Scotch. Although we do adore the various treats on offer at this stunning bakery, it’s the cakes that make this one of the best cake shops in NYC (as you might expect!). Each layer is baked to perfection, and the tasty frosting on each cake just melts in the mouth. 

You can order whole birthday cakes at Butter & Scotch. So, if you’ve got a special occasion coming up, then be sure to place an order for a personalized message!

Featuring an amazing silky sponge as well as a bunch of rainbow sprinkles, their birthday cake is a celebration cake like you’ve never seen before. Butter & Scotch truly is one of the best cake shops in NYC, so be sure to pay them a visit on your next trip to the city!


Mah-Ze-Dahr Bakery

Mah-Ze-Dahr is one of the best cake shops in NYC – hands down. Since 2014, this amazing bakery has been taking the city by storm. Serving up soft tarts, brioche buns, and of course, cakes, Mah-Ze-Dahr certainly deserves the title of the best cake shop in NYC.

If you’re looking for a standout cake that you need to order on your next trip to New York, then look no further than The Devil in Ganache. This indulgent chocolate cake has a rich coating of chocolate and whipped cream, making it one of the most devilish desserts that you can order. This is one of the best cake shops in NYC that you won’t want to miss!

If you fancy something slightly lighter, why not try their beloved carrot cake? Made with maple-cream cheese frosting and an ideal nut to batter ratio, this is one for the books. 


Lady M

If you want to feel as though you’re walking on air, give one of Lady’s M’s incredible crepe cakes a try. Layered with delicious pastry cream, this unique cake is like nothing else you’ll find in NYC. However, it’s not only the cakes that make this one of the best cake shops in NYC.

The service is always top-tier and the staff at Lady M will go above and beyond to find you that perfect dessert. Great food and great service? What more could you ask for? A fantastic choice for the best cake shops in NYC!

Read more food inspiration: Where to find the best pancakes in NYC


Milk Bar

Next on our list of the best cake shops in NYC, it’s Milk Bar. Featuring amazing treats like cereal-milk soft serves and freshly baked goods, Momofuku Milk Bar is one of the best cake shops in NYC. Their famous Birthday Cake is still a bestseller after many years, and it doesn’t surprise us one bit. Packed with a tower of cake crumbs and sprinkles, this cake is a delight.

Read more NYC food inspiration: Where to find the best cookies in NYC

All cakes here are frosted in the signature Milk Bar way; they are iced between the layers and on top but left bare at the sides. It’s an interesting look that is surprisingly aesthetic! So, if you’re looking for the best cake shops in NYC that offers one-of-a-kind treats and nationwide delivery, then look no further. Seriously, why would you not want to order a delicious cake once you get home from your trip? 


Erin McKenna’s Bakery

The final bakery on our list of the best cake shops in NYC is Erin McKenna’s Bakery. If you’re vegan and gluten-free, then your time has come! The goodies at Erin McKenna’s are free of harmful ingredients, making it the perfect place for those with allergies or food sensitivities.

This cake shop in NYC takes special care to select all ingredients responsibly, so you know that you’ll only be getting the good stuff. If we had to pick a couple of standout dishes, we’d say that the crumb cakes and ice lemon teacake certainly fit the bill. An amazing choice for the best cake shops in NYC!


Hopefully this list of the best cake shops in NYC has been helpful!

As you’ll have figured out by now, there are so many great choices for the best cake shops in NYC! There are some fantastic choice, and we know you’re going to love checking off these epic options for the best cake shops in NYC!

best cake shops in NYC

Read more food inspiration: Top 15 best desserts in Portland

You Might Also Like