Top 15 Places to Find the Best Pickles in NYC!

August 2, 2021

So you’re looking for the best pickles in NYC? Keep reading for 15 amazing recommendations!

If you’re in NYC and you’ve got a craving for pickles – then you absolutely need to check out some of these amazing places for pickles in NYC! This list is full of the best pickles in NYC, with 15 epic recommendations to keep you busy!

So, let’s get started! Ready to find out where to find the best pickles in NYC?


Here are 15 amazing places, to find the best pickles in NYC!


Jacob’s Pickles

If you’re looking for the best pickles in NYC, then you need to stop at Jacob’s Pickles. As you may have guessed from the name of this establishment, they’re all about the pickles. They pride themselves on Southern comfort food, craft beer, and of course, PICKLES.

You can order various types of pickles here, including Hot Sour Cukes, Special Sours, Sweet & Spicy Carrots, and even Thyme Jalapenos. You’ll really be spoiled for choice!

Don’t forget to try one of their many incredible drinks too. Though they specialize in craft beer, you can also grab some awesome speciality cocktails while you munch on your pickles. This place is amazing, and definitely some of the best pickles in NYC!


The Pickle Guys

Another place that serves up some of the best pickles in NYC is The Pickle Guys. Now, you’d hope that with a name like The Pickle Guys, that this place would know their stuff.

Luckily, they certainly do! You can pick up classic pickled cucumbers here, but these guys specialize in all sorts of pickled goodies such as pickled turnips and pickled pineapples! Another thing that makes these pickles some of the best pickles in NYC is the recipe they use.

Read more NYC food inspiration: The best pizza in Times Square (6 places to try!)

All pickles at The Pickle Guys are made using an old Eastern European recipe that was passed down through generations. With an authentic flavor, plenty of spices, and generous amounts of garlic, these pickles taste incredible. A great place to find some of the best pickles in NYC!


Katz’ Delicatessen

If you’re looking to grab some of the best pickles in NYC while you sit down for a full-blown deli dinner, then Katz’ Delicatessen is the place to be. The pastrami sandwich on rye and the steak frites are among some of the favorite dishes here, but people just keep coming back for the best pickles in NYC.

They’re the perfect mixture of sweet and sour, and they’re never too mushy either. So, if you’re looking to fill yourself up before a day of sightseeing or relax after a long day, then be sure to head here for some of the best pickles in NYC. 


Whitmans

Whitmans is next on our list of the best pickles in NYC. If you’ve ever wanted to sample fried pickles, then be sure to stop by Whitmans on your next trip to NYC. It may sound bizarre or even disgusting, but there’s something about these crunchy pickles that keeps visitors coming back.

If you can’t quite get on board with fried pickles being the best pickles in NYC, then you can also order a bowl of delicious local pickles. Perfectly seasoned and brined to perfection, you certainly won’t leave Whitmans disappointed. 

Read more NYC food inspiration: Top 50 best desserts in NYC


Horman’s Best Pickles

Horman’s know how to do pickles, and as a result, their pickles have been named as some of the best pickles in NYC. Their secret is keeping the pickles cold from ‘vine to brine’. When pickles for Horman’s are selected, they’re hydro-cooled and packed on ice.

Then, they’re pasteurized, packed, and seasoned with their famous Old World spice recipe. Although they’re often bought online, you can also visit these guys on 306 6th Avenue or at seasonal markets in Brooklyn! This is another great choice for the best pickles in NYC.

Read more about NYC food: Top 12 best places to eat in Little Italy, NYC


Pea & Pickles

If you’re looking to pick up some of the best pickles in NYC and some incredible deli food, then you’re in luck. Pea & Pickles is an amazing grocery store that just so happens to sell some of the best pickles in NYC. Located at 55 Washington Street, these guys are easy to find too! 


Brooklyn Brine

Brooklyn Brine sell some of the best pickles in NYC, and they’re also some of the most unique. Not only do they sell the classic NYC deli pickle, but they also sell the whiskey sour pickle, the damn spicy pickle, and the decadent maple bourbon bread and butter pickle.

All pickles at Brooklyn Brine are made by hand using high-quality ingredients, and these guys are committed to using only the best ingredients and glassware for their pickles. So, if you’re searching for the best pickles in NYC that come with a conscience, then these should be your go-to! 


Sahadi’s

Are you looking to elevate your pickle game and try something new? Well then, why not sample some of the best pickles in NYC at Sahadi’s? Now, the pickles at Sahadi’s are seriously artisan.

Not only are they bougie, but they’re packed with flavor. Their Dill Pickle and Moroccan Spice dish is a fan favorite, and their spice blend is not to be underestimated. Don’t believe us? Try the best pickles in NYC for yourself! 


Lucky Pickle Dumpling Co.

Located on Amsterdam Avenue, Lucky Pickle Dumpling Co. always sees large queues for its incredible food. In addition to serving up some of the best pickles in NYC, Lucky Pickle Dumpling Co. is also home to incredible noodle dishes, amazing dumplings and even house made teas!

One of the most unique things about this pickle place in NYC? They serve their pickles with ice-cream. Yes that’s right!

Although they’re super tasty, part of the reason for Lucky Pickle Dumpling Co. being on our list of the best pickles in NYC is the fact that they’re open late! Open until 2am on Fridays and Saturdays, this is the perfect spot to quell that late-night pickle craving. You’re going to love trying these best pickles in NYC!

Read more NYC food inspiration: The best cake shops in NYC (12 places you need to try!)


Maison Pickle

Specializing in American favorites, Maison Pickle is always packed with visitors. Most of the dishes at this spot are served with a side of the best pickles in NYC, so you’ll basically never miss an opportunity to try pickles while you’re dining here!

Depending on what you fancy, you can order an amazing deli sandwich or one of their more intense steak dishes. Whatever you fancy, you should be able to find something here that hits the spot. 


Guss’ Pickle

Not only are the pickles at Guss’ Pickle some of the best pickles in NYC, but they’re considered “world famous”! Having been around since 1920, the pickle recipe at Guss’ has evolved over time to reach perfect consistency and flavor.

Although their regular sour pickles are the top choice here, you can also order sour tomatoes and sauerkraut too! Hey, don’t knock it ‘til you’ve tried it! These are definitely some of the best pickles in NYC!

Read more NYC food inspiration: Where to find the best bagels in NYC


Rick’s Picks

Rick’s Picks are next on our list of the best pickles in NYC! On Grattan Street in Brooklyn, you’ll find the humble Rick’s Picks. Serving up everything from classic sours to hot pickled jalapenos, there’s something at this pickle stop for everyone.

However, it’s not just the best pickles in NYC that you can find here. You’ll also find various cookbooks and plenty of great chat too! The staff here are incredibly friendly, and a visit to Rick’s should leave you with a smile on your face.


Joseph Leonard

Although Joseph Leonard isn’t specifically dedicated to the art of the pickle, it is home to some of the best pickles in NYC. This place is a popular American bistro in the West Village which specializes in delicious food and presenting a rustic atmosphere.

You can order a side of pickles along with most dishes, so if you’re looking to sample some of the best pickles in NYC in true comfort, then Joseph Leonard is an excellent choice. 


Boulton and Watt

Not only do Boulton and Watt have one of the greatest brunches in town, but they also happen to be home to some of the best pickles in NYC! If you’re wondering what makes the pickles here the best pickles in NYC, then let us fill you in.

They have an actual pickle selection on offer at each table which includes beets with black pepper, pineapple, and the classic cucumber pickle. With so many options on offer, it’s no surprise that the pickles at Boulton and Watt are considered some of the best pickles in NYC!

Read more NYC food inspiration: Where to find the best cheap lunches in NYC


2nd Avenue Deli

For some of the best pickles in NYC, you need to check out 2nd Avenue Deli. These guys are famed for their deli sandwiches, but they also serve up some seriously mean pickles too.

Though many eateries will specialize in cucumber pickles, these guys have a large array of “sours” that you can choose from. If you want to make your trip to 2nd Avenue Deli a full New Yorker experience, then be sure to order one of their famous bagels. This is a great choice for the best pickles in NYC!


We hope this list of the best pickles in NYC has been helpful!

You Might Also Like