• Posted byby Elle-Rose
  • Updated:
  • 7 minute read

Have you been searching for amazing pizza in Brooklyn? If so, you’ve come to the right place!

If you’ve been on the lookout for the best pizza in Brooklyn but don’t want to sift through TripAdvisor, I’ve got you covered!

Some of the best pizza in the world can be found in Brooklyn and I would know! I’ve tried most of it!

I’ve rounded up a go-to list of places to grab the best pizza in Brooklyn without breaking the bank.

From square pies to standalone slices and Detroit-style gems, this list of the top Brooklyn pizzas has it all!

Now let’s get cheesy!

My helpful map of the best pizza places in Brooklyn…

I thought giving you a Google Map of all the pizza places on this list would be helpful. That way, you can see which are closest to your hotel (or apartment) and which are within walking distance to wherever you are.

I hope it helps! Everywhere mentioned below can be found on this map!

Barboncino Pizza

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/barboncinopizza/

First up on our list is Barboncino. This lively eatery is just steps away from the Brooklyn Museum on Franklin Avenue and it serves amazing brick-oven pizzas.

Not only is the crust beautifully chewy and perfectly charred, but you can add virtually any topping under the sun.

Artichoke, clams, smoked pancetta? It’s all up for grabs!

Joe’s Pizza

If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Brooklyn, NY, you can’t beat Joe’s.

The OG Joe’s Pizza was established by Joe Pozzuoli back in 1975 (who was from Naples, so you know it’s legit!).

These guys are known for serving traditional New York Slices, and the Manhattan location typically has queues that snake around the block.

But luckily for you, the Brooklyn location is much quieter and serves amazing sausage and pepperoni pizza.

The place is relatively no-frills, but all of the attention goes into the food here (and not the décor!)

Emmy Squared Pizza

Image credit: https://www.emmysquaredpizza.com/

Happen to be hanging around Williamsburg? If so, you’ll want to head right to Emmy Squared Pizza for the best pizza in Brooklyn, NY!

Now, this place has been so successful over the years that it’s franchised and has become a nationwide sensation.

And that’s largely down to its crunchy and super-savory Detroit-style pies.

The tomato sauce drenches each slice and you can’t go wrong with any of the toppings on offer.

But between you and us, it’s the cheesy garlic sticks that take the cake – just trust us on that one.

Read more food inspiration in NYC: Top 10 best pizza in Times Square

Speedy Romeo

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/speedyromeo/

  • Website: speedyromeo.com
  • Address: 376 Classon Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238
  • Phone:  +1 646-542-1848
  • Closest Subway stop: Bedford Ave/Greene Av

We couldn’t write a list of amazing Brooklyn pizzerias without including the iconic Speedy Romeo!

This place is known for its amazing hardwood-fired oven as it creates THE crispiest pies in town.

Not only do they offer classic mozzarella slices, but you can grab meaty delights like the King Salami pizza.

It’s topped with a glorious soppressata and is just mind-blowing.

The only thing you’ll need to be aware of before heading down is that they don’t sell pizzas by the slice here.

But honestly, you won’t want to stop at just one anyway!

L’Industrie

Image credit: https://www.lindustriebk.com/

  • Website: lindustriebk.com
  • Address: 254 S 2nd St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
  • Phone: +1 718-599-0002
  • Closest Subway stop: Marcy Av

If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Brooklyn, NY that’s relatively new to the game, try out L’Industrie!

This cool spot is adored by everyone from celebrities to Average Joes as the slices here are just next-level.

Seriously, just take a look at the burrata slice!

Better yet, the pies are all incredibly consistent and reliably delicious, meaning you won’t have a stellar piece followed by a soggy mess.

And hey, you can’t beat that thin and chewy crust that strikes the perfect texture balance!

Read more foodie inspiration in NYC: Top 28 pizza places in NYC, that you need to try!

Krispy Pizza

Image credit: https://krispypizza.com/gallery/

  • Website: krispypizza.com
  • Address: 7112 13th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11228
  • Phone: +1 718-745-9618
  • Closest Subway stop: 71 St

Next on our list of where to grab amazing pizza in Brooklyn is Krispy Pizza!

This is another spot that’s reliable and family-friendly, serving incredible square slices and pizza pies that’ll blow your mind.

But this isn’t the place to visit if you’re on the hunt for a classic pepperoni pizza (although you will find them!).

Nope, this place serves amazing Brooklyn pizza with a twist, as you’ll find everything from spicy vodka to salad pies hanging around!

This one’s for you, adventurous types.

Read more about NYC food: The best brunch in NYC – 15 places to try!

Julianna’s

Image credit: https://julianaspizza.com/gallery

  • Website: julianaspizza.com
  • Address: 19 Old Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
  • Phone: +1 718-596-6700
  • Closest Subway stop: York St

When you want the best pizza in Brooklyn, that tastes super fresh, you’ll want to head to Julianna’s.

This spot serves an amazing white pie that makes a change from classic marinara bases that you’ll find around the city.

The crust is super thin and crunchy (thanks to the coal-fired ovens!) and each topping is specially selected for freshness.

So, it’s no surprise that every single pie that comes out is considered awesome!

Just head down to Old Fulton Street and see for yourself.

Luigi’s Pizza

Luigi’s Pizza is the place to be for the best pizza in Brooklyn, NY if you appreciate classic flavors and perfect crusts.

Not only did this place win the Village Voice’s Iconic Foods of NY award for “Best Pizza” back in 2008, but it’s also a local favorite!

There’s not as much variation here as you’d find at other locations, but these guys do the basics right.

So, whether you’re craving a large square pie, a white pie, or a meatball bonanza, Luigi’s has got you covered!

Read more NYC food recommendations: What is the best bakery in NYC?

Grimaldi’s

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/grimaldispizzeria/

  • Website: grimaldispizzeria.com
  • Address: 1 Front St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
  • Phone: +1 718-858-4300
  • Closest Subway stop: York St

If you’re on the lookout for the best pizza in Brooklyn, that’s also on the historic side, you’ll adore Grimaldi’s.

This place has been rocking NYC’s pizza scene since 1945 and takes up an impressive 3 stories of real estate.

From its classic checked tablecloths to its friendly team of staff, it’s no surprise that this place is a total hit with locals.

What sets this place apart from other Brooklyn pizzerias is the fact that you can build your own creation.

So, whether you’re craving a Margherita or a prosciutto-topped delight, you’ll be able to make the magic happen.

Read more NYC food recommendations: Where to find the best bagels in NYC

Roberta’s

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/robertaspizza/

The first time we tried Roberta’s, we just knew we’d happened upon some of the best pizza in Brooklyn, NY.

Not only is each slice perfectly charred (never burnt!), but the classic ingredients and unique flavors are oh-so-delicious.

The crust is made in an industrial-size wood-fired pizza oven, and many slices are drizzled with honey for signature sweetness.

But if you’re more into spice, you can add everything from chili to anchovies!

And honestly, you’ll never forget their marinara sauce!

Lucali

  • Website: https://www.lucali.com/
  • Address: 575 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
  • Phone: +1 718-858-4086
  • Closest Subway stop: Carroll St

When it comes to the best pizza in Brooklyn, Lucali is up there.

It’s never been easy to grab a slice here as the queues frequently start around the block from 4 pm each day.

You can get tons of different pizzas by the slice, but you should try and grab the perfectly puffy calzone if you can.

Di Fara

Di Fara is another spot for the best pizza in Brooklyn, NY that’s been around for years (since 1965, to be exact!).

This place was owned by Domenico De Marco until he passed away in 2022, but his family has continued his legacy so well.

So, everything from the mozzarella to the tomatoes is brimming with authentic freshness.

And the proof’s in the pudding as the lines are always snaking around the block at peak mealtimes!

Paulie Gee’s

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/pauliegee/

If you want to grab a slice of the best pizza in Brooklyn, then you’ll want to make a beeline for Paulie Gee’s.

The pizza here tends to have a thinner crust, and that’s what makes it so wonderfully tasty.

And that’s just the way we like it!

The tomato sauce perfectly sits on top of the crust, and the pepperoni is always perfectly blackened (for ultimate crispiness!).

Oh, and did we mention that they even offer a 100% vegan pizza and a secret menu?

Read more NYC food ideas: Top 21 best diners in NYC

L&B Spumoni Gardens

Image credit: https://www.instagram.com/lbspumonigardens/

L&B Spumoni Gardens has been offering some of the best pizza in Brooklyn, NY since 1939.

So, these guys certainly know how to whip up Sicilian square slices for the masses!

The sauce here is famous for being slightly sweet but suitably tangy and it pairs beautifully with melty mozzarella.

And unlike other spots, this place uses a sophisticated deck oven that gives the crust a fluffy texture.

Although the pizza is the main event, you can’t go wrong with a scoop of their Spumoni for dessert!

Nonno’s Pizza

If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Brooklyn, NY that tastes just like an Italian grandma would make – this is it.

The mushroom and onion slice at Nonno’s is legendary, but virtually everything here is incredibly flavorful.

It’s on the easygoing side and functions more as a delivery and pickup spot.

But that means the prices are ridiculously cheap and you can pick up an entire round pizza for as little as $11.

Hopefully this list of the best pizza in Brooklyn, has given you plenty of idea for where to try next!

Read more: What pizza places are open on Christmas Day in NYC?